PracticeHow it worksFeaturesPricingBlog Start practising free
Past Paper Solutions

Atomic Structure JEE 2016: Decay Question Explained

JEE Advanced 2016 Chemistry Atomic Structure Nuclear stability and radioactive decay modes

By Founder, JEEnius - IIT Kanpur Alumni · Nov 20, 2026 · 4 min read

Medium 2 min target

A plot of the number of neutrons N against the number of protons P of stable nuclei exhibits upward deviation from linearity for atomic number Z>20. For an unstable nucleus having N/P ratio less than 1, the possible mode(s) of decay is(are)

Show answerAnswer

B) orbital or K-electron capture

D) β+-decay, positron emission

Explanation

For a stable nucleus, the neutron-to-proton ratio must lie in the stability belt. For heavier nuclei, stable nuclei need comparatively more neutrons, so the N/P ratio is generally greater than 1.

Here the given unstable nucleus has

NP<1

This means the nucleus is proton-rich. To become stable, it must increase the neutron-to-proton ratio.

In β+ decay, a proton changes into a neutron with emission of a positron and a neutrino:

p→n+e++ν

So the number of protons decreases and the number of neutrons increases. Hence N/P increases.

Therefore β+ decay is possible.

In K-electron capture, a proton captures an inner orbital electron and changes into a neutron:

p+e−→n+ν

Again, the number of protons decreases and the number of neutrons increases. Hence N/P increases.

Therefore K-electron capture is also possible.

In β− decay, a neutron changes into a proton:

n→p+e−+ν¯

This decreases N/P, so it is not suitable here.

Neutron emission also decreases the number of neutrons, so it further decreases N/P and is not suitable.

Thus the correct options are B and D.

Chemistry artwork for the article: Atomic Structure JEE 2016: Decay Question Explained

What is the answer to the Atomic Structure JEE 2016 decay question?

B and D are correct: electron capture and positron emission both increase the neutron–proton ratio. This Atomic Structure JEE 2016 question is from JEE Advanced, Paper 1, Chemistry, not JEE Main. It is multiple-correct, so more than one option can be selected.

The stable-nuclei plot has neutron count on the vertical axis and proton count on the horizontal axis. Light stable nuclei approximately follow: N=P

The trend bends upward for: Z>20

Select the processes that move an unstable nucleus towards the stability belt when: NP<1

The question-bank tag is medium difficulty. Its 90-second target is not measured student performance.

Which way must the neutron–proton ratio move?

The ratio must increase. In the official stability-belt framework, the given nucleus is proton-rich. A process that lowers its neutron–proton ratio moves in the wrong direction.

Define neutron count, proton count, atomic number and mass number:

N=neutron count,P=proton count
Z=P,A=N+P

Stable heavier nuclei generally need comparatively more neutrons, explaining the upward bend in the stability plot. For the given nucleus:

NP<1⟹N<P

Moving towards the stability belt does not guarantee that one decay produces a stable daughter. This question asks for the corrective direction, not a complete decay chain.

Why do positron emission and electron capture both work?

Both processes turn a proton into a neutron. The numerator of the neutron–proton ratio rises while its denominator falls, so the ratio increases.

Option D: beta-plus decay

The nuclear conversion is: p→n+e++ν

The emitted particles are a positron and a neutrino. The daughter counts and mass number are:

N′=N+1,P′=P−1
A′=(N+1)+(P−1)=A

Subtract the original ratio from the daughter’s ratio:

N+1P−1−NP&=P(N+1)−N(P−1)P(P−1)&=P+NP(P−1)>0(P>1)

Option B: orbital or K-electron capture

An inner-orbital electron is captured by the nucleus. It combines with a proton, producing a neutron and a neutrino: p+e−→n+ν

The count changes are identical:

N′=N+1,P′=P−1,A′=A

The same positive ratio difference applies. Electron capture changes the nucleus, not merely the electron arrangement.

Numerical check: use hypothetical counts of eight neutrons and ten protons, purely to check the arithmetic. After either process:

N=8,P=10,A=18,NP=810=0.8
N′=9,P′=9,A′=18,N′P′=99=1
Δ(NP)=1−0.8=0.2>0

Both B and D therefore increase the ratio by converting a proton into a neutron. The ratio argument establishes the intended directions in this question; actual decay availability for a specified isotope also depends on energetics.

Why are beta-minus decay and neutron emission incorrect?

Both lower the neutron–proton ratio, worsening the imbalance identified by the official solution. Beta-minus decay converts a neutron into a proton; neutron emission removes a neutron without changing the proton count.

Option A: beta-minus decay

A neutron converts into a proton, emitting an electron and an antineutrino: n→p+e−+ν¯

N′=N−1,P′=P+1

The ratio change is:

N−1P+1−NP&=P(N−1)−N(P+1)P(P+1)&=−P+NP(P+1)<0

Option C: neutron emission

The nucleus loses one neutron, but no proton:

N′=N−1,P′=P
N−1P−NP=−1P<0

Both differences are negative, so neither process corrects the proton-rich imbalance. The complete option audit is:

The official selection is B and D. Both raise the neutron–proton ratio.

What reasoning mistake leads to choosing beta-minus decay?

The mistake is treating the emitted particle’s negative charge as evidence that the nucleus loses a proton. The inference “negative beta means fewer protons” is wrong.

Beta-minus emission removes neither a pre-existing orbital electron nor a proton. A neutron converts into a proton while an electron is emitted, giving:

ΔN=−1,ΔP=+1

Writing only “an electron comes out” misses the nuclear change. Use this order instead of guessing from the decay label:

  1. Write the nucleon-conversion equation.
  2. Update both neutron and proton counts.
  3. Compare the new neutron–proton ratio with the original.

Can you apply the same method to three related questions?

Yes: update both nuclear counts, then compare the ratios. These are original practice questions, not additional verified JEE PYQs. Each includes its solution so you can check the method immediately.

Which beta process corrects an excessively high neutron–proton ratio?

Beta-minus decay moves the ratio downward, the required direction for an excessively high ratio relative to the stability belt. A neutron becomes a proton:

N′=N−1,P′=P+1
N′P′=N−1P+1<NP

Option A was rejected in the original question because it lowers the ratio. That same change is useful for the opposite imbalance.

What are the daughter’s mass number and atomic number after one K-electron capture?

Mass number stays unchanged; atomic number decreases by one. Substitute these daughter values into the neutron-count expression:

A′=A,Z′=Z−1
N=A−Z
N′=A′−Z′=A−(Z−1)=A−Z+1=N+1

The neutron count increases by one because a proton becomes a neutron. No nucleon leaves the nucleus, so mass number stays unchanged.

Can mass-number and atomic-number changes distinguish positron emission from electron capture?

No. Both processes leave mass number unchanged and reduce atomic number by one:

A′=A,Z′=Z−1

Beta-plus decay emits a positron, while electron capture consumes an orbital electron. To identify which occurred, check the particles involved, not just the parent and daughter numbers.

Next step: the past-paper archive on JEEnius and search every JEE Main paper from 2002 and every Advanced paper from 2007, by year, subject or chapter, each with a worked solution (free).

If that step was the hard part, work through Thermodynamics JEE 2016: Why the Net Heat Is 588 J.

Frequently asked questions

What is the answer to the Atomic Structure JEE 2016 decay question?

B and D are correct: electron capture and positron emission both increase the neutron-proton ratio by converting a proton into a neutron. The question is from JEE Advanced 2016, Paper 1, Chemistry, not JEE Main. It is a multiple-correct question.

Why is beta-minus decay wrong when the neutron-proton ratio is less than 1?

In this question, the proton-rich nucleus needs an increase in its neutron-proton ratio to move towards the stability belt. Beta-minus decay converts a neutron into a proton, decreasing the neutron count and increasing the proton count. This lowers the ratio, so option A moves in the wrong direction.

What happens to mass number and atomic number during K-electron capture?

Mass number remains unchanged, while atomic number decreases by one. The nucleus captures an inner-orbital electron, which combines with a proton to form a neutron and a neutrino. The neutron count therefore increases by one.

How can I distinguish positron emission from electron capture?

Check the particles involved: positron emission releases a positron, while electron capture consumes an orbital electron. Both processes leave mass number unchanged and reduce atomic number by one. Parent and daughter mass numbers and atomic numbers alone cannot distinguish them.

atomic structureelectron capturejee advancednuclear stabilityradioactive decay

Practise this with JEEnius AI

25 years of PYQs and AI doubt solving, plus 10 free 2027 predicted questions.

Start practising free