What is the answer to the Units and Measurements JEE 2016 question?
A, B and D are correct in the Units and Measurements JEE 2016 question on error in measured gravitational acceleration. This is JEE Advanced 2016, Paper 2, Physics, a multiple-correct question, not a JEE Main single-correct MCQ.
The experiment estimates gravitational acceleration using:
The measured lengths are:
Five period readings are 0.52, 0.56, 0.57, 0.54 and 0.59 seconds. The watch has a least count of 0.01 seconds.
Assess these four claims:
How do you check option A and calculate the mean period?
Option A is correct, because the smaller length has an absolute error of 1 mm against a measured value of 10 mm. The mean period is 0.556 seconds. Keep that unrounded mean for calculating the five deviations, although the official solution records the period as approximately 0.56 seconds.
Absolute error carries the same unit as the measurement. Fractional error is absolute error divided by the measured value:
Average all five period readings, then record the official rounded value:
How do the five readings give a 3.57% error in time?
The official solution uses an absolute time error of 0.02 seconds, obtained by rounding the mean absolute deviation. This exceeds the watch’s 0.01-second least count. Dividing the rounded absolute error by the rounded period, then multiplying by 100, gives 3.57%.
Calculate each absolute deviation from 0.556 seconds:
- Reading 1:
- Reading 2:
- Reading 3:
- Reading 4:
- Reading 5:
Average these absolute deviations:
The measured scatter gives the larger error here, so the official solution takes:
Its rounding sequence, before calculating the percentage, is:
B is correct; C is incorrect. Use this mean-absolute-error calculation here, not standard deviation, standard error or quadrature. This is the official solution’s treatment, not a universal statistical uncertainty prescription.
How do you propagate the length and time errors to g?
The percentage error in gravitational acceleration is approximately 11%, so D is correct. The measured length difference contributes 4%, while the squared period contributes about 7.14%. In the limiting-error calculation used here, these contributions add despite the subtraction and division in the formula.
Square the supplied relation, then rearrange:
The numerical prefactor is exact and introduces no measurement uncertainty. The length difference is:
Measured values subtract, but their absolute error bounds add. The worst-case error occurs when one measured length shifts upward and the other shifts downward:
The fractional-error rule is:
The inverse-square dependence contributes a positive factor of 2 to the error bound, not a negative contribution:
Substitute the values:
Millimetres cancel in the length ratio, so no SI conversion is needed:
Option verdict: A true, B true, C false, D true. Select A, B and D.
How can a calculation mistake produce option C?
One possible wrong calculation multiplies the numerical value 0.02 directly by 100 and reports 2%. It skips division by the measured period. This is a possible mistake, not a claim about how the option was designed or how often students choose it.
Keep these three quantities separate:
- Absolute error:
- Fractional error:
- Percentage error:
A percentage must come from a dimensionless ratio. An uncertainty still carrying seconds is not a percentage.
What three follow-up questions check the same error rules?
Calculate the errors in the larger length, the sum of the lengths and the squared period. These are original follow-up practice based on the same data, not additional verified PYQs.
What is the percentage error in the larger length R?
The percentage error is approximately 1.67%. Both lengths have identical 1 mm absolute errors, but the larger measured value has the smaller percentage error:
Compare this with the 10% error in the smaller length.
What is the percentage error in the sum of the two lengths?
The percentage error is approximately 2.86%. Absolute error bounds add for a sum, just as they do for a difference:
For the difference, the same absolute error is divided by a smaller value:
What is the percentage error in the squared period?
Using the official rounded time values gives 7.14%. Squaring doubles the fractional error in this propagation rule:
This is the time contribution in the gravitational-acceleration calculation. Before checking another answer, write the absolute error, fractional error and percentage error on separate lines, with units shown until they cancel.
Next step: photograph a doubt on JEEnius and photograph any question you are stuck on and get a step-by-step solution, with a free-body diagram when the question needs one (20 free).
Read next: Polymers Practice Questions JEE: 6 Free Solved Drills.
Frequently asked questions
What is the answer to the Units and Measurements JEE 2016 question?
Options A, B and D are correct; C is incorrect. The question is from JEE Advanced 2016, Paper 2, Physics, and allows multiple correct answers.
How is the percentage error in time calculated as 3.57%?
The five readings give a mean period of 0.556 s and a mean absolute deviation of 0.0208 s. The official solution rounds these to 0.56 s and 0.02 s before calculating the percentage error. Thus, (0.02/0.56) × 100 gives approximately 3.57%.
Why do errors add when calculating R minus r?
In a limiting-error calculation, the largest error in a difference occurs when one measurement shifts upward and the other shifts downward. Therefore, the absolute error bounds add: 1 mm + 1 mm = 2 mm. Since R − r = 50 mm, its percentage error is (2/50) × 100 = 4%.
How is the percentage error in gravitational acceleration 11%?
Rearranging the supplied relation gives g = (28π²/5)(R − r)/T². The limiting fractional error is Δg/g = Δ(R − r)/(R − r) + 2ΔT/T. Using the official rounded time values, the percentage error is 4% + 2 × 3.57% = 11.14%, approximately 11%.