What is the properties of roots JEE 2024 question asking?
Both statements are true, so option 1 is correct in this properties of roots JEE 2024 question. “Cannot be” needs an impossibility proof; “may be” needs proof of compatibility, not necessity.
The chapter is Complex Numbers and Quadratic Equations, and the question bank’s difficulty tag is Hard. Three positive numbers satisfy:
The specified non-unit root satisfies:
The quadratic is:
Which statements hold?
- Statement I: A non-unit root strictly between negative one and zero rules out the middle number being the geometric mean of the other two.
- Statement II: A non-unit root strictly between zero and one is compatible with that geometric-mean relationship.
How do Viète’s formulas identify both roots?
One root is exactly one, and the other is the constant coefficient divided by the leading coefficient. Use Viète’s formulas rather than the quadratic formula: subtracting the product of the roots from their sum exposes the unit root directly.
First define the denominator:
Both differences are positive under the given ordering. The equation is therefore genuinely quadratic, and division by this denominator is valid.
Let the roots be:
Viète’s formulas give:
Subtract the product from the sum, keeping the brackets:
Rearrange and factor:
The specified root is not one, so the other root must be one. The product formula gives:
The denominator is positive, so the numerator alone determines the sign of the non-unit root. This reduces both statements to inequalities involving the three positive numbers.
Why is statement I true when the non-unit root is negative?
A negative non-unit root forces the middle number above the arithmetic mean of the outer numbers. That arithmetic mean is strictly greater than their geometric mean, so equality with the geometric mean is impossible.
Using the positive denominator:
The strict AM–GM inequality follows from a square. The square is positive because the outer numbers are distinct:
Dividing by two gives:
Combining the inequalities:
Thus the geometric-mean condition is ruled out, and statement I is true. Negativity alone proves this implication; the lower endpoint, negative one, is not needed for the impossibility argument.
Why is statement II true for a root between zero and one?
The geometric-mean condition produces a non-unit root strictly inside the required interval. Positivity is only half the proof: the numerator must also be smaller than the positive denominator.
Assume:
The ordering remains valid because:
The numerator is strictly positive:
Hence the non-unit root is positive. To check the upper endpoint, subtract the numerator from the denominator:
Therefore:
An explicit example confirms compatibility:
“May be” means compatible, not compulsory. It does not claim that every ordered triple producing a root between zero and one satisfies the geometric-mean condition.
Statement II is therefore true. The official final answer is both I and II are true, so option 1 is correct.
How can confusing the two means lead to a wrong answer?
Replacing the geometric mean with the arithmetic mean tests a different condition and forces the non-unit root to zero. This substitution could lead to the incorrect conclusion, “I is true, II is false.”
The incorrect substitution is:
It gives:
Zero lies in neither stated open interval. That could make both intervals appear incompatible with a “mean” condition, but the calculation tests the arithmetic mean only.
The correct definition is:
Keep the logical tests separate: statement I requires exclusion, while statement II requires compatibility. A zero obtained from the wrong definition establishes neither claim about the geometric mean.
Which two practice questions check the same method?
Use these two original practice questions, not verified PYQs, to test the root formula and the geometric-mean condition. The first gives a negative-root example; the second checks an entire geometric-mean family.
What are both roots when the coefficients use four, three and one?
The roots are one and negative one-fifth, and the geometric-mean condition fails. Original practice 1: In the same quadratic, take the following values, find both roots and check the geometric-mean condition.
Substitution gives:
Using the root formula:
The geometric-mean condition fails because:
What interval contains the non-unit root for a geometric-mean family?
The non-unit root lies strictly between zero and one. Original practice 2: In the same quadratic, find the non-unit root and determine its interval when:
These assumptions ensure the required ordering and geometric-mean relationship:
Substitute into the root formula and cancel the positive common factor:
Cancellation is valid because:
The interval follows from:
Check your work against this contrast: the negative-root example excludes the geometric mean, while the whole geometric-mean family produces a positive non-unit root below one.
Next step: the past-paper archive on JEEnius and search every JEE Main paper from 2002 and every Advanced paper from 2007, by year, subject or chapter, each with a worked solution (free).
For a worked example of the same idea, see Biomolecules JEE 2016: Invert Sugar Question Explained.
Frequently asked questions
What is the correct option in the properties of roots JEE 2024 question?
Option 1 is correct: both statements are true. A non-unit root between −1 and 0 rules out b² = ac, while a non-unit root between 0 and 1 is compatible with b² = ac.
How do I find the non-unit root without the quadratic formula?
For (a+b−2c)x² + (b+c−2a)x + (a+c−2b) = 0, the coefficients sum to zero, so one root is 1. Viète’s product formula then gives the non-unit root α = (a+c−2b)/(a+b−2c). Under 0 < c < b < a, the denominator is positive.
Why does a negative non-unit root rule out b being the geometric mean?
Under 0 < c < b < a, the denominator of α = (a+c−2b)/(a+b−2c) is positive, so α < 0 forces b > (a+c)/2. Strict AM–GM gives (a+c)/2 > √(ac), hence b > √(ac). Therefore b² > ac, ruling out the geometric-mean condition.
Does a non-unit root between 0 and 1 mean b must equal √(ac)?
No: the geometric-mean condition is compatible with that interval, not compulsory. If b = √(ac) and 0 < c < b < a, then a+c−2b > 0 and (a+b−2c)−(a+c−2b) = 3(b−c) > 0, proving 0 < α < 1. This proves the required possibility, not the converse.