What is the smallest final orbit number in the JEE Advanced 2017 question?
The required entry is 5 for the Bohr model of hydrogen atom JEE 2017 question. This PYQ is from JEE Advanced 2017, Paper 1, Physics, chapter Atoms. It is a single-digit integer-answer question, not an MCQ with supplied options.
A hydrogen electron changes from an initial orbit to a final orbit, labelled respectively:
Its initial potential energy divided by its final potential energy is:
Find the least permitted final quantum number. Both energy symbols mean potential energies, not electric potentials or total energies.
How do you turn the potential-energy ratio into an orbit-number ratio?
Start with the Bohr-radius dependence: radius is proportional to the square of the principal quantum number. Potential energy depends on inverse radius, so the energy ratio contains the final quantum number’s square in the numerator.
The electron’s potential energy in hydrogen is:
The electrostatic constant and the magnitude of the electron charge are denoted, respectively, by:
Substituting the radius dependence gives:
The same positive constant applies to both hydrogen orbits. Write the full quotient before simplifying:
The minus signs cancel because a negative quantity divided by another negative quantity is positive. Separately, dividing by an inverse square means multiplying by its reciprocal. That puts the final quantum number’s square in the numerator.
Substitute the given value:
Only the positive square root is allowed. Both principal quantum numbers are positive integers, so their ratio cannot be negative.
Why is the minimum final quantum number 5 rather than 2.5?
The number 2.5 is a ratio, not an orbit number. Both quantum numbers must be positive integers. Since five over two is already reduced, every permitted pair must be a positive integer multiple of that pair.
The first three allowed initial-to-final pairs are:
Choose the smallest positive multiplier:
Setting the initial quantum number to one fails. It requires a forbidden non-integer final quantum number:
Check the permitted minimum pair directly:
The final orbit has a larger quantum number, so its potential energy is less negative, with a smaller magnitude. Dividing the more negative initial energy by the less negative final energy gives a positive ratio greater than one, as required.
How can reversing the ratio produce the wrong integer entry 2?
The integer 2 can result from reversing the quantum-number ratio. It is an illustrative wrong entry, not an official answer option. The mistake is treating potential energy as proportional to the quantum number squared, rather than its actual negative inverse-square dependence.
The incorrect setup is:
It leads to:
But radius and potential energy have different dependences:
Substitute the proposed pair into the correct relation:
The pair fails the given ratio. To avoid this reversal, write the quotient of the two negative energy expressions before cancelling anything, rather than recalling the ratio from memory.
Can you apply this method to three related Atoms questions?
Use the same method to reduce a new ratio, handle a downward transition and connect orbit numbers to radius. The questions below are original practice variations, not additional verified PYQs.
For a potential-energy ratio of 2.25, what is the smallest final quantum number?
For hydrogen, the smallest final quantum number is 3, with initial quantum number 2. Reduce the square root to its lowest fractional form before selecting orbit numbers.
For a potential-energy ratio of four ninths, what is the smallest final quantum number?
For hydrogen, the smallest final quantum number is 2, with initial quantum number 3. This is a downward transition: “final” does not mean the larger orbit.
For the transition from orbit 2 to orbit 5, what is the radius ratio and is energy absorbed?
For the original minimum transition, the final-to-initial radius ratio is 6.25, and the atom absorbs energy. Radius follows the square of the quantum number directly; absorption follows from the move to a higher total Bohr energy level.
For a Bohr orbit, total energy is half the potential energy:
The absorbed photon supplies the total-energy increase, not the potential-energy increase alone. Before accepting any orbit pair, substitute it into the original potential-energy ratio.
Next step: photograph a doubt on JEEnius and photograph any question you are stuck on and get a step-by-step solution, with a free-body diagram when the question needs one (20 free).
Read next: How to Study Polymers JEE: Syllabus, Structures and Recall.
Frequently asked questions
What is the answer to the Bohr model question in JEE Advanced 2017?
The required integer entry is 5, the smallest permitted final quantum number. The given potential-energy ratio of 6.25 gives n_f/n_i = 5/2, so the smallest allowed pair is n_i = 2 and n_f = 5.
How is potential energy related to the orbit number in the Bohr model?
For hydrogen, the orbit radius is proportional to n squared, while potential energy is V_n = -C/n², where C is a positive constant. Therefore, V_i/V_f = n_f²/n_i². Writing both negative energy expressions before simplifying prevents reversal of the ratio.
Why is the minimum final orbit 5 and not 2.5?
The value 2.5 is the ratio n_f/n_i, not the final orbit number. Both quantum numbers must be positive integers, so the reduced ratio 5/2 requires n_f = 5m and n_i = 2m for a positive integer m. The smallest choice, m = 1, gives n_f = 5.
Does hydrogen absorb energy when an electron moves from orbit 2 to orbit 5?
Yes, hydrogen absorbs energy because orbit 5 has a higher, less negative total energy than orbit 2. The absorbed photon supplies the total-energy increase, not the potential-energy increase alone. In a Bohr orbit, total energy is half the potential energy.