What is the correct answer to the simultaneous equations JEE 2023 question?
The simultaneous equations JEE 2023 question has a unique solution for every permitted real parameter, so the correct answer is option 4. It is from JEE Main Mathematics, 24 January 2023, morning shift, in Matrices and Determinants. The parameter is real and nonzero:
Classify the permitted values into these sets:
The given system is:
The supplied data does not include the complete option list. We can establish the answer sets without inventing option wording.
How do you write the coefficient matrix and choose the method?
Use the coefficient determinant rather than solving for the three unknowns. A nonzero determinant guarantees exactly one solution, whatever the right-hand-side constants are. The question asks for parameter sets, not the solution coordinates.
Write the system in matrix form:
The test is:
Follow the supplied solution by expanding along the first row. Keep all three minors visible until their polynomial products have been simplified.
How do you expand all three minors without a sign error?
The first-row cofactor signs are positive, negative, positive. The third contribution carries a negative sign because its matrix entry is negative. Keep the cofactor sign separate from the entry’s sign when multiplying.
The full expansion is:
Each minor is the product on its main diagonal minus the product on its other diagonal. Expand both products before subtracting.
First minor:
Second minor:
Third minor:
Substitute these expressions without changing the signs outside their brackets. The second and third contributions now have positive coefficients term by term.
Collect the cubic, quadratic and linear terms separately, then factor out the parameter:
Why does the quadratic factor lead to option 4?
The quadratic has no real zeros because its discriminant is negative. Its leading coefficient is positive, so the quadratic is positive for every real input. Combined with the nonzero parameter restriction, this proves that the determinant never vanishes in the allowed domain.
Therefore:
Do not say the determinant is always positive. It is negative for negative parameter values, but a negative determinant still guarantees uniqueness.
The requested sets are:
Hence option 4 is correct. No singular permitted case remains, so this question needs no further consistency test.
Why does the option-2 reasoning fail?
The option-2 error identified in the supplied solution treats the quadratic factor as if it supplied two real parameter values giving infinitely many solutions. This makes two separate mistakes: assuming real roots without checking them, then assuming a zero determinant establishes infinitely many solutions.
First, degree is not real-root count. A quadratic has two roots counting multiplicity over the complex numbers, but it need not have any real roots. Here, the proposed real parameter values do not exist because:
Second, singular does not mean consistent. A zero determinant only rules out uniqueness. For a three-variable system, the criteria are:
- Infinitely many solutions:
- No solution:
Check outside the allowed domain: setting the parameter to zero turns the first equation into a contradiction. This excluded singular value gives no solution, not infinitely many:
Can the same determinant give infinitely many solutions in one system and none in another?
Yes. The coefficient determinant detects loss of uniqueness, but the right-hand sides determine whether the singular system is consistent. These original related practice questions, not additional verified PYQs, use identical coefficients to isolate that distinction.
Question 1: For a real parameter, classify the solutions of:
The coefficient determinant and the result of subtracting the first equation from the second are:
When the determinant is nonzero, the solution is unique:
At the singular value, both equations are identical. One variable is free, giving infinitely many solutions:
Question 2: Classify the system with only the second right-hand side changed:
The determinant stays the same, but subtraction gives:
The nonsingular case has the unique solution:
For a numerical check:
At the singular value:
so there is no solution. Identical coefficient determinants do not distinguish infinite solutions from inconsistency at the singular parameter: check the right-hand sides before classifying that case.
Next step: the past-paper archive on JEEnius and search every JEE Main paper from 2002 and every Advanced paper from 2007, by year, subject or chapter, each with a worked solution (free).
For a worked example of the same idea, see Redox Reactions and Electrochemistry JEE 2016: Nernst Solution.
Frequently asked questions
What is the answer to the simultaneous equations JEE 2023 question?
The correct answer is option 4 for the JEE Main Mathematics question from 24 January 2023, morning shift. The system has exactly one solution for every nonzero real parameter a, so S1 is all nonzero real numbers and S2 is empty.
How do you find the determinant in the JEE 2023 simultaneous equations question?
Expand the coefficient determinant along the first row, using cofactor signs +, −, +. The three minors simplify to a² + a + 1, −a² − 3a − 3 and −4a² − 8a − 10. Combining the contributions gives det(A) = a(15a² + 31a + 37).
Why is the determinant nonzero for every allowed value of a?
The quadratic factor 15a² + 31a + 37 has discriminant −1259 and a positive leading coefficient, so it is positive for every real a. Since the question excludes a = 0, det(A) = a(15a² + 31a + 37) cannot vanish. The determinant is negative when a is negative, but it still guarantees a unique solution.
Does a zero determinant mean infinitely many solutions?
No: a zero coefficient determinant only rules out a unique solution. Infinitely many solutions require rank(A) = rank([A|B]) to be less than the number of unknowns; unequal ranks mean no solution. In this question, the excluded value a = 0 makes the first equation 0 = 1, so it gives no solution.